The thought of making fresh, homemade pizzas can be intriguing. Why not? You get to make healthy and delicious pizza to your taste.
This feeling often only lasts for a while, especially when you can’t seem to make the dough fluffy, moist possibly, and rise uniformly. That pang of anger you feel when you make an indentation that never fills can be heartbreaking.
And you don’t have to tell me all about it: the dense, flaky, and crumbly results are never what anyone expects.
Oddly enough, the secret to making well-proofed pizza dough is using the right proofing box. Simply right?
There’s more to that;
So, I’m revealing my top THREE best pizza dough proofing boxes. They stick less and are more space efficient for easier and better handling for a consistent round pizza.
In a Short Of Time? Here’s a Quick Summary of the Best Dough Proofing Boxes
DoughMate Artisan Dough Tray Kit – is a complete kit for beginners and seasoned chefs. It has two super-sturdy and stackable basins that fit into any home refrigeration. Each box can hold up to 6 dough balls and is covered with a lid for ZERO heat and moisture loss. Plus, there’s a FREE plastic scraper for easy dough retrieval.
GSM Pizza Dough Proofing Box – features a super durable plastic construction. It handles the rigors of daily use better than most products. It’s stackable as well and offers enough space to cold ferment up to 6 dough balls. Unlike other options on this list, it comes with two lids for more value for money.
Tescoma Dough-rising bowl with warmer – features an innovative warmer gel for the quickest proofing experience. It has a 4L bowl to make a large dough pizza effortlessly by shaking. Thanks to its warmer gel and airtight seal, this product is twice as fast as its competitors.
*If you click any of these links and make a purchase, we earn a commission at no additional cost to you.
A proofing dough box or proofing container earns its place in large pizzerias and restaurants. It offers enough space for more than four dough balls.
Also, they are great containers for storing the pizza dough. Keep in mind these commercial settings need to store a lot of them.
Thanks to their stackable design, pizzaiolos can easily store the excess without eating up extra space.
Their application is not limited to commercial purposes alone. Home cooks can take advantage of them. They come in pretty handy for storing several small pizza doughs or bread dough. Besides, they can improve your proofing results.
Want to keep your dough balls properly proofed? Try out a pizza dough proofing container with a lid. This specialty container maintains the dough’s moisture content in its resting state.
It’s not a must-have pizza accessory. However, the tricky part is you can never tell when you might need one to store multiple pizza dough.
Most home chefs bake 1 – 2 pizzas occasionally. So, it’s easier to pull this feat off with a baking bowl with plastic wrap or a Tupperware container.
Now, the question is, how many baking bowls would you need for a pizza party? Besides, you have a higher chance of ruining the balls with that small-sized bowl.
So, do you need a proofing box? Yes, if you:
- Want an accessory to manage and move several dough balls
- Hate dough balls sticking to each other
- Wish to keep the surface moist instead of dried and flaky
- Need your dough balls in the right shape for a perfectly round pizza
How To Choose The Best Dough Pizza Proofing Box?
When shopping for a proofing box, there are several important factors to consider:
Back in the day, proofing containers were made of wood. These traditional accessories look unique, fantastic, and aesthetically useful.
However, they do not offer reliable airtight seal performance. Hence, the engendering of modern plastic pizza-proofing boxes.
Unlike their traditional wooden counterpart, plastic-proofing containers are more safe-efficient, easy to handle, and stackable.
Most importantly, these newer models have a smoother surface for a non-stick performance. So, no more hassle taking your dough out of the box.
Also, these proofing boxes are made of glass. If you are purchasing a plastic model, it should be made with food-grade materials.
Regardless of your option, cleaning won’t require time and effort. Even better, you might be able to toss them into your dishwasher.
One of the reasons to buy a proofing box is its ample space. Else, you’ll be better off with a baking bowl or Tupperware container.
So, it’s vital that you purchase one that offers enough space to hold a sufficient amount of dough balls. Larger models are your best bet for people in the food service industry.
They come in the right size to meet your 100-pizza-per-hour demand. If that’s you, consider the standard 12-dough-ball proofing boxes.
For home chefs, they can be troublesome to use and store because of their large size. Luckily, there are smaller boxes that hold less than 12.
Another thing you want to pay attention to is the box’s height. The regular ones are about 3 inches tall. They are suitable for most types of pizza, from New York to Neapolitan pizzas.
However, you might need taller proofing boxes if you are proofing large pizza dough balls. Otherwise, the dough balls might struggle to rise properly.
An airtight-proof box prevents your dough from drying out. This is a massive win for me since I love to ferment the dough a bit longer.
Keeping the dough moist is quite crucial for a full rise. So, you don’t want to gamble on some loose models.
An airtight seal helps protect your well-kneaded dough from insects, dirt, etc. otherwise, your dough balls might rise completely with a foreign, awkward taste or dry out.
The chief purpose of purchasing a proofing container is to offer a smarter storage option. The right one should be stackable to store a lot of dough balls without needing real estate in your workstation.
Another reason to go for a stackable model is easier to transport your dough. These boxes sit on each other firmly. So, moving more than two boxes at a time is drop-free.
Best Pizza Dough Proofing Box Reviews
1. DoughMate Artisan Dough Tray Kit
The DoughMate Artisan Dough Tray Kit is the best pizza dough-proofing container, thanks to professional-quality construction, improved interlock feature, and its handy plastic scraper.
If you need a product with everything you need, this is it. This starter kit comes with two dough trays, a DoughMate plastic putty scraper, and a lid.
Artisan Dough Tray Highlights
- Artisan Dough Tray
- 17 3/4 in (W) x 12 3/4 in (D) x 3 in (H)
- Airtight and dustproof when nested
- The material will not support bacterial growth or absorb odors or contaminants.
- Heavy duty long, life construction
- Lid sold separately
- No knockout pin impressions to reduce sticking issues
- Chemical resistant material
- FDA Compliant Copolymer Polypropylene material—BPA Free
This brand has always been the go-to for many top pizzaiolos. So, I’m glad they are offering this starter kit to get home chefs started with fermentation.
One of the many pleasing things about this product is its professional-grade quality construction. It’s lightweight for easy handling and heavy-duty to handle the rigors of everyday use. You get that when a proofing box is made of Super High Impact Copolymer Polypropylene.
With home chefs in mind, this leading manufacturer designed this product to be the best pizza dough box for space efficiency. Each tray measures 17.75 “L x 13 “W x 7 “H, with sufficient space to hold decent-sized 5 to 6 dough balls.
Remember, the manufacturer includes two trays, so you have plenty of proofing space to host a party.
These two trays are compact enough to fit into your regular refrigerators. This compactness comes in handy if you prefer cold fermentation—no need to re-organize your refrigerator space to create room for this proofing box.
The manufacturer included just one lid. So, there’s no way of storing the dough balls separately, except you stack them. This can be challenging if you need more vertical room in the refrigerator.
But here’s a massive plus;
DoughMate Artisan Dough Tray features a cutting-edge Interlocking Design. Not only does this feature allow you to stack the trays but keep it airtight. ZERO worries about dried-up dough balls.
If you are okay with coughing up a couple of dollars for the best products, the DoughMate Artisan Dough Tray Kit is everything you need. Except you want to try your luck with cheaper models. Just don’t come back crying when your dough balls never rise properly or get annoyingly flaky.
2. Pizza Dough Proofing Box – Stackable Commercial Quality Trays with Covers
The GSM Pizza Dough Proofing Box remains one of the most recommended proofing boxes for home chefs.
And that’s not even why it ranks #2 on my list.
Its super durable commercial-quality plastic construction, 100% airtight seal performance, and affordable price point earn it a top spot.
On top of that;
This product comes in a luster white finish that feels premium. It’s more than 3-inch tall. Top Italian chefs say that’s enough height to make the perfect dough for your favorite Neapolitan or new york pizza.
The amount of space it offers is generous enough for 6 250g dough balls. To make the deal better, it comes with two trays to double its storage capacity.
While you won’t get a plastic scraper, the trays are super smooth for effortless dough release. The downside is you might have to use your hands or improvise. Plus, the lids don’t not close as tightly as the DoughMate Artisan Dough Tray Kit.
Here’s where it stands out;
This product retails at lower than my favorite DoughMate Artisan Dough Tray Kit. And, instead of one lid, it comes with two. One is for proofing doughs, while the others can double as a storage space for your vegetables. This way, you can use the tray independently with the lid.
Like the best-selling DoughMate Artisan Dough Tray Kit, this unit is stackable if you want. It makes cold fermentation for days worry-free. You don’t have to create much space from these two basins.
You don’t have to pay much to have these two sturdy basins and one EXTRA lid for slow proofing. They are super versatile, offering more value for money. Do you think something else beats GSM Pizza Dough Proofing Box? Good luck on the quest then; you’ll need plenty of that anyway.
3. Tescoma Dough-rising bowl with warmer
Leaving the best for the last is starting to seem like my habit. The Tescoma Dough-rising bowl with warmer has an innovative proofing system, which is surprisingly simple yet effective.
Unlike the others, this model keeps your yeast dough warm enough for quick proof. It takes less than half the time it took the other two products on this list.
The secret is its warmer gel.
You can easily heat up the gel in hot water or your microwave. Then place it under the bowl and watch how the heat proofs the dough quickly.
The lid is not so transparent, meaning you can’t track the process without opening it. Well, it isn’t a terrible deal-breaker. The lid bulges like some sort of notification when the dough gets proof enough.
Nonetheless, the lid is super airtight to trap the present moisture for a better proofing performance.
It’s more like the traditional pizza proofing boxes, but it is better with the warmer gel.
While it’s not so great for keeping several pizza dough balls, it’s the best option for proofing yeast dough almost instantly.
Pizza Proofing Box Alternative
If you prefer to bake in a Dutch oven, then you might be better off with a proofing basket. It’s a sure way to achieve that refined round shape.
After the fermentation process, allow the dough to proof on the counter in the proofing basket. This accessory will help shape the dough roundly. However, it won’t help with proofing the dough.
OXO Leakproof Storage Container Highlights
- Durable borosilicate glass containers designed to go from freezer to oven
- Smart Seal glass containers nest and stack for convenient and compact storage
- Lids are interchangeable between the same size glass and plastic Smart Seal containers
- Borosilicate glass is naturally BPA free and stainproof
The same goes for home chefs using loaf pans. Plant the dough in the loaf pan and let the ambient humidity and warmth do the trick on your counter.
Another excellent method is using your oven. Instead of allowing the dough to proof on the counter, you can take advantage of your warm oven. The Tescoma Dough-rising bowl with warmer shares the same core principle.
However, you need to place about three cups of boiling water on the bottom rack while the dough goes to the top rack of the oven. Do not turn on the device. It takes less than 2 hours to have a well-proof dough without costing a thing.
Can you proof pizza dough overnight?
Pizza dough can sit on your counter overnight, provided it’s lean. This means the dough only contains about four ingredients – yeast, water, salt, and flour.
The scary part is that it might be overproof if left out for more than 10 hours. So, as long as you can control the timing, it’s safe to proof the dough overnight. Else, it gets springy and less elastic.
How long should pizza dough be proof for?
Cold fermentation, proofing in a refrigerator, takes about 24 hours to proof. You can go the other route by leaving it on the counter for quick proofing. This process is short and usually less than 10 hours.
Should I proof pizza dough in the fridge?
Using the best pizza dough box, you should be able to store it in the refrigerator for up to 2 weeks.
However, it’s essential that the container is airtight to prevent the dough from drying out. For the best flavor, it’s recommended to embrace cold fermentation.
All in all, your pizza will only be as good as the accessories, tools, and ingredients used!
But what else can you expect from dried-out pizza dough, if not poor-quality pizzas and a demoralized home chef?
Choosing the correct pizza-proofing container is imperative if you want a crispy crust and chewy middle result.
I’ve reviewed the best three out there, used mainly by top Italian chefs at home. Now, it’s up to you to make a choice.